Pizza Month 2025....copyright Sean Taylor 2002-2018

Congratulations to Pizza Month 2025 Slicey Award winners....

BEST PIE......De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies (Yardley, Pennsylvania)

BEST SLICE.......Andrea's Pizza (East Village, NYC)

BEST DISCOVERY.........Lucky Charlie (Bushwick, Brooklyn)

DAY 1: OCTOBER 1st

Ceres

164 Mott St,
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 01, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		3.5/5
AMBIENCE:		2.5/3
TASTE:		9/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
14/18 = 0.778 x 5 = 3.89

DAY 2: OCTOBER 2nd

Serano's Italian

132 W 31st St
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 02, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			8.5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
17/21 = 0.81 x 5 = 4.05

DAY 3: OCTOBER 3rd

Lucia Pizza of UES

1571 3rd Ave
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 03, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		3.5/5
AMBIENCE:		2.5/3
TASTE:		8/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
13/18 = 0.722 x 5 = 3.61

DAY 4: OCTOBER 4th

Kid Pizza

157 W 18th St
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 04, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			7.5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
16/21 = 0.762 x 5 = 3.81

DAY 5: OCTOBER 5th

Diamond Slice

70 Diamond St
Brooklyn, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 05, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		8/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
15/18 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165

DAY 6: OCTOBER 6th

Traze

21-03 45th Rd
Long Island City, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 06, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		8.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
15/18 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165

DAY 7: OCTOBER 7th

Ops (E. Village)

176 2nd Ave
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 07, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			8.5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
17/21 = 0.81 x 5 = 4.05

DAY 8: OCTOBER 8th

Turbo Pizza

1540 DeKalb Ave
Brooklyn, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 08, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		3.5/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		7.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
13/18 = 0.722 x 5 = 3.61

DAY 9: OCTOBER 9th

Andrea's Pizza

50 2nd Ave
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 09, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4.5/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		9/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
16/18 = 0.889 x 5 = 4.445

DAY 10: OCTOBER 10th

Scott's New Oven

Brooklyn, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 10, 2025
OVERALL:

DAY 11: OCTOBER 11th

Pennings Orchard

169 NY-94
Warwick, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 11, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		2.5/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		6.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
11/18 = 0.611 x 5 = 3.055

DAY 12: OCTOBER 12th

Lucky Charlie

254 Irving Ave
Brooklyn, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 12, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			4.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			9/10
SERVICE:			3/3
19/21 = 0.905 x 5 = 4.525

DAY 13: OCTOBER 13th

PizzArte

69 W. 55th St
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 13, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			8.5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
17/21 = 0.81 x 5 = 4.05

DAY 14: OCTOBER 14th

L&B Spumoni Gardens (DUMBO)

46 Old Fulton St
Brooklyn, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 14, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			4.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			8/10
SERVICE:			3/3
18/21 = 0.857 x 5 = 4.285

DAY 15: OCTOBER 15th

De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies (Yardley)

1707 Yardley Langhorne Rd
Yardley, PA

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 15, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			10/10
SERVICE:			3/3
21/21 = 1 x 5 = 5

DAY 16: OCTOBER 16th

Stretch Pizza (Wmburg)

320 Kent Ave
Brooklyn, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 16, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		9/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
16/18 = 0.889 x 5 = 4.445

DAY 17: OCTOBER 17th

Slicehaus Pizzeria

30 Carmine St
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 17, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4/5
AMBIENCE:		2/3
TASTE:		8.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
14/18 = 0.778 x 5 = 3.89

DAY 18: OCTOBER 18th

2Amys Pizza

3715 Macomb St NW Suite 201
Washington, DC

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 18, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			8/10
SERVICE:			3/3
17/21 = 0.81 x 5 = 4.05

DAY 19: OCTOBER 19th

Cugino Forno Pizzeria

1160 Revolution Mill Dr
Greensboro, NC

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 19, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		2.5/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		5.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
10/18 = 0.556 x 5 = 2.78

DAY 20: OCTOBER 20th

Valerie's Home Pizza

Statesville, NC

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 20, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		0/5
AMBIENCE:		0/3
TASTE:		0/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
Not Applicable

DAY 21: OCTOBER 21st

LLoyd's Restaurant & Lounge

900 DeKalb Ave NE
Atlanta, GA

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 21, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			4/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			8/10
SERVICE:			3/3
18/21 = 0.857 x 5 = 4.285

DAY 22: OCTOBER 22nd

The National Tavern

1145 National Dr
Greensboro, GA

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 22, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			7.5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
16/21 = 0.762 x 5 = 3.81

DAY 23: OCTOBER 23rd

Vinnie Van GoGo's

317 W Bryan St
Savannah, GA

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 23, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		2.5/5
AMBIENCE:		2.5/3
TASTE:		5.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
9/18 = 0.5 x 5 = 2.5

DAY 24: OCTOBER 24th

Prima Pizza Cucina

112 Sams Ave
New Smyrna Beach, FL

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 24, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			4/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			9/10
SERVICE:			3/3
19/21 = 0.905 x 5 = 4.525

DAY 25: OCTOBER 25

Voodoo Brewing Co. (Valrico)

3432 FL-60
Valrico, FL

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 25, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			2.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
13/21 = 0.619 x 5 = 3.095

DAY 26-27: OCTOBER 26th & 27th

Pizza Expo (Columbus)

400 N High St
Columbus, OH

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 11, 2026
OVERALL:
VALUE:		0/5
AMBIENCE:		0/3
TASTE:		0/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
Not Applicable

DAY 26: OCTOBER 26th

TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia

1210 S James Rd
Columbus, OH

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 26, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			4/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			7.5/10
SERVICE:			3/3
17/21 = 0.81 x 5 = 4.05

DAY 27: OCTOBER 27th - Part 1

Mikey's Late Night Slice

457 N High St
Columbus, OH

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 27, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		6.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
13/18 = 0.722 x 5 = 3.61

DAY 27: OCTOBER 27th - Part 2

DiCarlo's Pizza (Columbus)

15 E 2nd Ave
Columbus, OH

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 27, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4.5/5
AMBIENCE:		2.5/3
TASTE:		9.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
15/18 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165

DAY 28: OCTOBER 28th

Pies & Pints (Carmel)

14550 Clay Terrace Blvd Suite 100
Carmel, IN

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 28, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:			3.5/5
AMBIENCE:			3/3
TASTE:			7/10
SERVICE:			3/3
16/21 = 0.762 x 5 = 3.81

DAY 29: OCTOBER 29th

Nolita Pizza

68 Kenmare St
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 29, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		3.5/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		7/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
13/18 = 0.722 x 5 = 3.61

DAY 30: OCTOBER 30th

Mama's TOO! (West Village)

325 Bleecker St
New York, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 30, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		8.5/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
15/18 = 0.833 x 5 = 4.165

DAY 31: OCTOBER 31st

Mano's Pizzeria

62-98 Forest Ave
Ridgewood, NY

(click to open full multimedia review)

Latest Rating: Oct 31, 2025
OVERALL:
VALUE:		4.5/5
AMBIENCE:		3/3
TASTE:		9/10
SERVICE:	N/A	0/0
16/18 = 0.889 x 5 = 4.445